Luke 5:31 Meaning: When Jesus Calls Himself the Physician
Jesus answered them, “Those who are healthy have no need for a physician, but those who are sick do.
And Jesus answering said unto them, They that are whole need not a physician; but they that are sick.
And Jesus answering said unto them, They that are in health have no need of a physician; but they that are sick.
And Jesus answering said unto them, `They who are well have no need of a physician, but they that are ill:
And Jesus answering said to them, They that are in sound health have not need of a physician, but those that are ill.
Meaning in one sentence
Jesus uses a physician metaphor to show why he eats with sinners. Does it mean the Pharisees are truly healthy? A closer look at Luke 5:31.
Context
Jesus calls Levi, a tax collector, to follow him. Levi leaves everything and throws a great feast in his house, inviting many other tax collectors and people the religious leaders considered sinners. The Pharisees and scribes are watching, and they complain to Jesus’ disciples: why does your teacher eat and drink with such people? Jesus hears them and responds. He does not defend himself by listing his deeds. Instead he reaches for a simple picture that anyone would understand, a physician and the people who need one.
Key Words
Luke, the writer of this gospel, was a physician himself. So it is fitting that the key words here carry a medical tone. ὑγιαίνοντες (hugiainontes) means those who are in sound health, who are well. Luke uses this word elsewhere for physical healing. But here it describes people who think they have no spiritual sickness. Then κακῶς ἔχοντες (kakōs echontes) means those who are badly off, miserable, sick. The contrast is not between good and bad people, but between those who feel fine and those who know they are suffering. And ἰατρός (iatros) is the physician. Jesus places himself in that role. He is not here for people who already believe they are whole. He comes for those who are desperate enough to admit they need a doctor.
How Christians Read This Verse
Most commentators see Jesus using the Pharisees’ own self image. The Pharisees thought of themselves as righteous, keeping the law, and therefore not in the same category as tax collectors and sinners. Some Christians read the verse as a simple observation: Jesus is where the need is, the way a doctor works in a hospital. Others go deeper. The Cambridge Bible notes that the Pharisees were actually sick themselves, but they did not feel their own sickness. They fancied only that they had no need of Jesus. In that reading the verse carries a gentle warning. Both views agree on the main point: Jesus came for people who know they are not well.
A common misunderstanding
A common misreading is to think Jesus was saying the Pharisees were truly healthy, that they had no sin and therefore did not need him. In fact, Jesus is using their own words back to them. They saw themselves as whole, and he lets that stand for a moment. But the rest of the Gospel makes clear that everyone is sick with sin. The Pharisees simply would not admit it. Jesus is not endorsing their view of themselves; he is explaining why his mission takes him to the sinners who know they are sick.
Living This Out
This week you might find yourself in a room full of people who seem to have it together. It can be tempting to act like you do too. But Jesus is not looking for people who can fake wellness. He is looking for people who will say, “I am sick, and I need a physician.” That honesty is the door. You do not need to clean yourself up before you come to him. You come because you are not clean. Let yourself feel the relief of that today. You do not have to pretend. Just tell him where it hurts.
Main takeaway: Jesus came as a physician for people who know they are spiritually sick, not for those who think they are well.
For Families
For ages 5, 8
When you are sick, you go to a doctor. Jesus says he is like a doctor for people who know they have done wrong things. He wants to help us, not send us away.
For ages 9, 12
The Pharisees thought they were good enough that they did not need Jesus. But Jesus came to help people who know they need him. Nobody is perfectly healthy inside. The first step is to admit we are sick, and then Jesus can heal us. He is always ready to help people who are honest about their need.
Questions People Ask
Why did Jesus say the healthy don't need a doctor?
Jesus was using a picture everyone understood. In that moment, the Pharisees acted like they were spiritually healthy, while the tax collectors knew they were not. Jesus was saying he came for people who recognize their own sin, not for those who think they are fine.
Was Jesus saying the Pharisees were sinless?
No. Jesus was not agreeing that the Pharisees were actually sinless. He was using their own claim of righteousness to show why he was eating with sinners. Later in the Gospel he makes clear that the Pharisees also need repentance. They just did not feel their sickness yet.
What does the word 'physician' mean in this context?
The Greek word is iatros, a healer. Luke the physician uses this term carefully. Jesus presents himself as a doctor whose patients are people sick with sin. He diagnoses and heals, but only those who come to him for treatment.
How does this verse connect to repentance?
The very next verse (Luke 5:32) says Jesus came to call sinners to repentance. The image of the physician sets the stage: just as a sick person must admit illness before seeing a doctor, a sinner must admit wrongdoing before turning from it. Repentance begins with honesty about our condition.
Why did the Pharisees complain about Jesus eating with tax collectors?
In Jewish culture at that time, sharing a meal meant fellowship and acceptance. Tax collectors were seen as traitors and thieves. The Pharisees thought a holy teacher should avoid such people. Jesus surprised them by showing that his holiness drew him toward the sick, not away from them.
For pastors & researchers
Greek interlinear, 8 commentaries & word study