Joshua 24:20 Meaning: When Good Turns After Being Done Good
If you forsake Yahweh, and serve foreign gods, then he will turn and do you evil, and consume you, after he has done you good.”
If ye forsake the Lord, and serve strange gods, then he will turn and do you hurt, and consume you, after that he hath done you good.
If ye forsake Jehovah, and serve foreign gods, then he will turn and do you evil, and consume you, after that he hath done you good.
When ye forsake Jehovah, and have served gods of a stranger, then He hath turned back and done evil to you, and consumed you, after that He hath done good to you.'
If ye forsake Jehovah, and serve strangegods, then he will turn and do you hurt, and consume you, after that he hath done you good.
Meaning in one sentence
Joshua warns Israel that if they forsake God, He will turn and harm them. Why does God's goodness not erase the reality of judgment?
Context
Joshua is old, close to death. He has gathered all Israel at Shechem for one last covenant ceremony. He rehearses their history, how God called Abraham, rescued them from Egypt, led them through the wilderness, and gave them the land. Then he puts a choice before them: serve the Lord, or serve the gods of the nations around them. The people respond quickly: “We will serve Yahweh.” But Joshua knows them. He knows their hearts. So he presses back, warning them that God is holy and jealous, and that their promise means nothing if they later turn away. This verse is the sharp edge of that warning.
Key Words
Three Hebrew words carry the weight here. The verb shuv (turn) means to turn back or change direction. It does not mean God becomes a different God, it means His actions toward His people shift in response to their choice. When they turn from Him, He turns toward them in judgment. The word for do harm is ra‘a, the same root as “evil.” God does not become evil, but He allows the consequences of covenant-breaking to strike His people. And kalah (consume) carries the sense of bringing something to an end, like a fire that finishes what it burns. These are hard words. But they come after a long list of good gifts. God is not quick to harm; He is slow to anger. Yet His goodness does not make His holiness optional.
How Christians Read This Verse
Christians across traditions have felt the weight of this verse. Matthew Henry saw Joshua warning the people because he knew their proneness to wander. The Geneva Bible notes emphasize the seriousness of forsaking God after receiving His benefits. Keil and Delitzsch highlight that Joshua’s warning is meant to jolt them out of shallow promises, pointing them to rely on God’s grace, not their own strength. Wesley describes God turning as a change in the way He deals with us, from kindness to severity. All agree: God’s goodness does not cancel the reality of judgment. The warning itself is an act of love.
A common misunderstanding
Some read this verse and think God is fickle, loving one moment, cruel the next. In fact, God does not change. His character is constant: He is holy, jealous for His people, and truthful about what happens when we abandon Him. The “turning” is not a mood swing but a consistent response to covenant unfaithfulness. He warns so that we will not have to suffer the consequences.
Living This Out
Joshua’s warning lands on people who have every reason to trust God, they have seen His miracles, eaten His provision, and received a land they did not build. Yet he knows how quickly good gifts can become idols. Maybe your week is full of good things: a stable job, a healthy family, a comfortable routine. Those are gifts from God. But when you start leaning on them instead of Him, they become foreign gods. This week, ask yourself honestly: is there anything you are serving more than the One who gave it? Identify it. Then ask God to help you turn back, before the turning becomes costly.
Main takeaway: God’s goodness does not cancel His holiness; turning away from Him leads to real loss, but He warns us because He wants us to return.
For Families
For ages 5, 8
God gives us good things, like a family and a home. If we stop loving Him and start loving those things more than Him, He will be sad. He wants us to choose Him first.
For ages 9, 12
Joshua warned the people because he loved them. God’s warnings are like a parent saying, “Don’t touch the stove”, He knows what hurts us. When we turn away, God doesn’t stop being good, but He lets us see what happens so we will come back. That’s why He warns us before it’s too late.
Questions People Ask
What does 'he will turn and do you evil' mean? Does God change?
God does not change in His character or His love for His people. But when they turn away from Him, He turns in His actions, from blessing to discipline. It is like a father who must correct a child running toward danger. God's turning is a consistent response to covenant unfaithfulness, not a mood swing.
Is God's goodness conditional?
God's goodness is always genuine, but His covenant relationship with His people includes both blessing for faithfulness and consequences for unfaithfulness. He does good because it is His nature, but He also warns that persisting in rebellion leads to harm. The condition is not earning His love, but living in the covenant He established.
What are 'foreign gods' in our lives today?
Foreign gods are anything we trust, love, or serve more than God, money, approval, comfort, career, relationships, even good things like family or health. Joshua called the people to 'put away the foreign gods' (v23), which means identifying what competes for your heart and deliberately setting it aside.
How is this verse consistent with God's love?
God's love includes warning. A loving parent does not let a child run into traffic without shouting. This verse is part of Joshua's final plea to keep the people from destroying themselves. God's warning is an act of love, giving them a chance to turn back before judgment falls.
Why does Joshua say 'You cannot serve the Lord' (v19) and then the people promise anyway?
Joshua was showing them that their own strength is not enough, they need God's grace. By saying 'you cannot,' he was not stopping them but exposing their weakness so they would rely on God, not themselves. The people's promise was sincere, but Joshua knew they would later fail without deep repentance and divine help.
For pastors & researchers
Hebrew interlinear, 8 commentaries & word study