John 9:36 Meaning: Who Is He?, and a Heart Ready to Believe
He answered, “Who is he, Lord, that I may believe in him?”
He answered and said, Who is he, Lord, that I might believe on him?
He answered and said, And who is he, Lord, that I may believe on him?
he answered and said, `Who is he, sir, that I may believe in him?'
He answered and said, And who is he, Lord, that I may believe on him?
Meaning in one sentence
Why the healed blind man asks 'Who is he, Lord?' after experiencing Jesus' power. A glimpse of a heart ready to believe.
Context
This man had been blind from birth. Jesus made mud, put it on his eyes, told him to wash in the pool of Siloam, and he came back seeing. The Pharisees interrogated him. He stood his ground and said plainly, “If this man were not from God, he could do nothing.” So they threw him out of the synagogue. When Jesus heard about it, he went looking for him. Finding him, Jesus asked a direct question: “Do you believe in the Son of God?” The man had never seen Jesus before. He had no idea the person standing in front of him was the one who had healed him. His answer is a question full of longing and readiness.
Key Words
Three small Greek words carry the weight of this moment. The word for Lord (kurie) was a polite address, like saying “Sir” to a respected stranger. The man does not yet know he is speaking to the Messiah, but by verse 38 he will fall down and worship Jesus, calling him Lord with full faith. The word for believe (pisteusō) means to entrust yourself completely, not just to agree with facts. The man wants to put his whole life in the hands of this One. And many ancient manuscripts add a small and before “who” (“And who is he?”), which makes the question eager and urgent, like a child tugging your sleeve. This is not confusion; it is a heart stretching toward the light.
How Christians Read This Verse
Calvin saw in this question a man ready to embrace Christ as soon as he was pointed out. Matthew Henry highlighted Jesus’ care in seeking the man after he had been rejected by the religious leaders. Wesley observed that the desire to believe already implies some degree of faith. Across traditions, Christians have read this exchange as a picture of honest seeking. The man does not pretend to know what he does not know, and Jesus does not rebuke him for asking. Instead, Jesus meets his question with revelation. What binds Catholic, Protestant, and Orthodox readers together here is the recognition that a longing for Christ, even when it is still learning his name, is already the work of grace.
A common misunderstanding
Some readers assume the blind man’s question shows he had no faith at all, that he was spiritually ignorant despite the miracle. In fact, the commentators point out the opposite. His words are full of eager desire. He had already defended Jesus before the Pharisees and suffered for it. He is not doubting; he is asking to be shown so he can believe. The question is not a mark of unbelief but of a faith that wants to know its object.
Living This Out
Maybe you feel like you have been pushed away by others because of your faith. Or perhaps you have questions about Jesus that feel embarrassingly basic, “Who is he, really?” The blind man shows you can bring those questions to Jesus with an open heart. He doesn’t demand that you have everything figured out. He asks if you want to believe, and when you say yes, he reveals himself. This week, try turning your honest questions into a prayer: “Lord, I want to believe. Show me who you are.”
Main takeaway: A sincere question asking who Jesus is can be the first step of faith, and Jesus always answers.
For Families
For ages 5, 8
The blind man could see with his eyes, but he didn't know Jesus yet. He asked, “Who is he?” It is okay to ask questions about Jesus. He will help you know him.
For ages 9, 12
The blind man had been healed by Jesus, but he didn't realize it was Jesus talking to him. He didn't pretend to know everything. He asked a straight question, and Jesus answered by saying, “It is me.” When you don't understand something about God, don't be afraid to ask. Jesus is happy to show you who he is.
Questions People Ask
Why didn’t the blind man recognize Jesus after being healed?
The man had never seen Jesus before. Jesus healed him, sent him to wash, and then the Pharisees interrogated him. When Jesus found him later, the man still didn’t know what Jesus looked like. He was ready to believe as soon as Jesus pointed him out.
Was the blind man’s use of 'Lord' a sign of deep faith or just politeness?
The word 'Lord' (kurie) could be a respectful address like 'Sir.' Many commentators think he was using it politely at first. But by the end of the passage, after Jesus reveals himself, the man says 'Lord, I believe' and worships him. His reverence grew as he understood more.
What does this verse teach about faith and knowledge?
It shows that you can have a desire to believe even without full knowledge. The man didn’t yet know that Jesus was the Son of God, but he was ready to trust him when shown. Faith often begins with a longing, not with a complete answer.
Does this verse mean we should ask questions about Jesus before believing?
Yes, questions are welcome. The man asked a sincere question and Jesus answered gently. Across Christian traditions, this passage is seen as an example of honest seeking. You don’t have to pretend to have all the answers; you can come to Jesus with your questions and let him reveal himself.
How does this verse connect to the rest of John chapter 9?
Chapter 9 shows a progression: the man receives physical sight, then spiritual sight. He defends Jesus, is cast out, and finally meets Jesus and believes. This verse is the turning point where his faith becomes personal. It contrasts with the Pharisees who claim to see but remain blind.
For pastors & researchers
Greek interlinear, 8 commentaries & word study