GospelMount
Search Topics Scripture Prayer Resources Ebooks About Support the mission Saved articles
Jump to ▾

John 5:47 Meaning: Believing Moses Points to Christ

But if you don’t believe his writings, how will you believe my words?”

Meaning in one sentence

Jesus asks why the Jewish leaders refuse to believe Him when they claim to believe Moses. The answer shows the Old Testament points to Him.

John New Testament Greek

Context

Jesus had just healed a man on the Sabbath, and the religious leaders were furious. In the long conversation that follows, Jesus lays out the witnesses that testify about who He is. John the Baptist, the miracles, and the Father Himself all bear witness. Then Jesus turns to a document they revere above all others: the writings of Moses. The people trusted Moses for their standing before God, but Jesus says that Moses himself will accuse them, because he wrote about Jesus. This verse is the sharp conclusion that follows that claim. If they do not believe what Moses wrote about the coming Messiah, how can they possibly believe the words of the Messiah standing in front of them?

Key Words

Two words stand in contrast here. The 'writings' of Moses are gramma in Greek. It means something written down, a document. For the Jewish leaders, gramma meant the sacred Scriptures, especially the books of Moses, which they treated as the highest authority. Jesus uses their own reverence for the written Word to press them. The 'words' Jesus speaks are rhema, which means a spoken saying or declaration. The point is not that writings are better than spoken words. The emphasis falls on whose words they are: his writings (Moses) versus my words (Jesus). The verb for believing appears twice. In Greek the first is present tense: you do not believe Moses’ writings. The second is future: will you believe my words? The present tense suggests a continuous refusal. The future tense asks what will happen when the spoken word of Christ confronts them directly. The logic of the question is built on what they already claim to accept. If the foundation (Moses) has not really been trusted, the building (Christ) has no chance.

How Christians Read This Verse

Christian readers have understood this verse in different ways that all point to the same truth. John Calvin noted that Jesus accommodates His argument to the high view the Jews held of Moses, not because Moses is greater, but because they would listen to what they already trusted. The Cambridge Bible for Schools and Colleges points out that the contrast is between Moses and Christ, not between writings and words. The emphasis is on 'his' versus 'My.' Matthew Henry sees the argument as unanswerable: if they reject the testimony of the man they claim to follow, they have no ground to receive the One he wrote about. Lange observes that Moses is easier for beginners and that through him people come to Christ. Across these traditions, the shared conviction is that the Old Testament serves as a preparation that points to Jesus, and rejecting its clear testimony is a refusal to follow where it leads.

A common misunderstanding

A common misreading is that Jesus is saying Moses is more trustworthy than He is, or that the Old Testament matters more than the New. In fact, Jesus is not lowering His own authority. He is using the leaders’ own commitment against them. They profess to believe Moses, but Moses wrote about the Messiah. If they truly believed Moses, they would recognize Jesus. The problem is not with Moses or Scripture; it is with their hardened hearts. The verse shows how closely the Old and New Testaments are tied together. One leads to the other.

Living This Out

This week, try this simple practice. Before you read any passage from the Old Testament, pause and ask: 'Where does this point to Jesus?' Not every verse will show Him directly, but the whole story leads to Him. The Jewish leaders had the Scriptures but missed the Saviour. They treated the writings as an end in themselves. You and I can do the same thing, treating the Bible as a rulebook or a collection of moral stories, while missing the Person it reveals. Let the words of Moses and the prophets do what they were meant to do: lead you to trust the Word made flesh.

Main takeaway: Faith in the Old Testament writings is hollow if it does not lead to faith in the Christ they reveal.

For Families

For ages 5, 8

Jesus said that if you believe what Moses wrote, you should also believe Jesus. The Old Testament tells us about Jesus. So we read the Bible to learn about Him.

For ages 9, 12

Jesus is speaking to people who thought Moses was the most important. He tells them that Moses wrote about Him. So if they really believed Moses, they would believe Jesus. It is like the whole Bible is a story that points to Jesus. When you read the Old Testament, you can ask: how does this tell me more about Jesus? That is what it is for.

Questions People Ask

What are 'his writings' in John 5:47?

They refer to the books of Moses, also called the Torah or the Pentateuch. The Jewish leaders treated these writings as the foundation of their faith. Jesus uses their own reverence for these Scriptures to show that they should lead to Him.

Why does Jesus contrast 'his writings' with 'my words'?

Jesus is not saying writings are better than spoken words. He is contrasting the authority of Moses with His own authority. The leaders claimed to believe Moses, but Moses wrote about the coming Messiah. If they really believed Moses, they would accept Jesus. The contrast exposes their inconsistency.

Does John 5:47 mean the Old Testament is more important than the New Testament?

No. Jesus uses the Old Testament as a starting point because the leaders already accepted it. The verse shows that the Old Testament was written to point forward to Christ. Both Testaments work together. Rejecting either one means missing the full picture of God's plan.

How does this verse relate to Luke 16:31?

In Luke 16:31, Abraham says that if people will not listen to Moses and the prophets, they will not be convinced even if someone rises from the dead. Both verses teach that the Scriptures already give enough testimony to the truth. Hardness of heart, not lack of evidence, is the real problem.

For pastors & researchers

Greek interlinear, 8 commentaries & word study

Study page →